25 December 2005

The most wonderful gift

As I finish setting the gifts around the tree, and get ready to settle in for a short winter's nap (kids get up early on Christmas, y'know), I thought I'd share some reflections on The Gift behind all these other gifts.

Christmas begins with the amazing promise that Mary "'will give birth to a son. And he will be called Immanuel.' The name Immanuel means 'God with us.'" (Matthew 1:23)

What's so amazing about that? some people say. Look at the Greek and Hindu myths. Lots of cultures have stories of "gods" coming to earth.

Those are stories of gods disguising themselves in human forms. They don't become human; they just put on a human costume. Often they visit on a whim to have some sport with us or let us entertain them for a while.

Christmas is an entirely different kind of "God with us" story. It's a God who was born as we are, grew just as we grow, and experienced what we experience. He came to be one of us. He came to feel what we feel and know what we know.

"And the child grew and became strong. He was very wise. He was blessed by God's grace." (Luke 2:40) As Jesus grew, he experienced all the joys and sorrows, all the strengths and weaknesses, all the glories and despairs of human life.

Stephen Crane wrote, "A man said to the universe: 'Sir, I exist!' 'However,' replied the universe, 'The fact has not created in me a sense of obligation.'"

The gift of Christmas offers a rather more optimistic view of life. The ultimate reality in the universe is not philosophy's "unmoved mover" or science's inexorable, impersonal physical laws. Ultimate reality is a person who knows and cares.

The Bible promises Jesus "can feel it when we are weak and hurting" and he "has been tempted in every way, just as we are." (Hebrews 4:15) He has faced the trials and challenges we face, and he can help us face them successfully.

When we cry out in our joys and sorrows, the answer is not a cosmic shrug, "So what?" It is the rather warmer "I remember what that felt like and I can help you through it."

This truly is the most wonderful gift of Christmas: God with us, to stand by us and help us. When we cry out to Jesus, he answers, "I am here for you."

May that hope give us a truly happy new year!

22 December 2005

"Being right is wrong," he said. "Are you right about that?" I asked

"Being right is wrong," the retired minister titled his reflection. After more than sixty years dealing with religion, he was discouraged. "As I watch religion function in this country and around the world, rather than experiencing hope, there is a great deal of disappointment."

The reason for his disappointment is one that resonates with many modern people. "The most divisive and damaging attitude is our insistence on being right. It is a global disaster and a local malady. ... Human beings are simply not privy to absolute truth."

This insistence on being right, the author declares, divides communities, nations, even families. And he is not alone in finding that a troubling thing. He concludes, "If the Spirit of God, through any religion, is to make humans gracious, then the attitude of being right paralyzes that function. To hold a personal, absolute, position on matters of faith is to miss the point."

Yet, it is the author who has missed the point. Think for a moment about what he has said. My editorial comments appear like this:
If the Spirit of God, through any religion, is to make humans gracious, then the attitude of being right paralyzes that function. [And I know I am right about this.] To hold a personal, absolute, position on matters of faith is to miss the point. [And I am absolutely sure about this.]

The argument collapses in self-contradiction. Is the statement "it's wrong to be right" right or wrong? If the statement is right, then it is wrong. And if it is wrong, then why try to persuade people it is right? And yet, that is exactly what the writer has tried to do.

Every religion claims the goal of putting the adherent in touch with ultimate reality, with truth beyond time. In Christianity, for example, as Jesus put it, the purpose of the Spirit of God is to lead us into truth. Polite and gracious behaviour grows out of that pursuit of the truth. It's important to be gracious in the pursuit of truth, but let's not confuse the method and the goal.

05 October 2005

In the Katrina disaster, who abandoned whom?

O. Benjamin Sparks, interim editor of The Presbyterian Outlook, posted an interesting defense of the role of government in the Katrina disaster. His editorial, Abandoned people, principles suggested the disaster should cause us to put an end to "the anti-government rhetoric in which our culture has been awash in recent decades."

He writes, "We are responsible for one another, and government -- not the voluntary sector -- is our first defense against anarchy." This is interesting, since it was government, not the voluntary sector, that left dozens -- perhaps hundreds -- of buses idle on the parking lot when they could have been used to evacuate the needy. And it was government, not the voluntary sector, that scaled back levee maintenance, diverting millions into pork barrel projects to benefit well-connected interest groups. And it was officials in the government, not the voluntary sector, that passed the buck at most every opportunity, inventing tragic tales of nursing home suffering to make sure people knew just whom (else) to blame.

Government dumped people in the Superdome without first making sure there were adequate stocks of food and water, leaving people to fend for themselves. The voluntary sector mobilised to make sure people were warmly and humanely welcomed to the Astrodome.

It is true, "To respond to such devastation, we do not rely alone upon the good and kind hearts of the American people." Yes, we rely upon police and armed forces to preserve order. Yes, we rely upon firefighters and EMS workers in the disaster scene. But kindness and mercy and compassion and walking humbly and faithfully before God are not job descriptions for civil service positions. It is a voluntary response when a person sees needs and hears the call of God. It's not the job of the government. It's the job of the citizens.

23 August 2005

A Church that gives us what we want isn't what we want

In last Saturday's Toronto Star, David Haskell, assistant professor of journalism at the Brantford campus of Wilfrid Laurier University, contemplated the precipitous decline in the United Church of Canada's membership.
In many ways the decline of the United Church flies in the face of common sense. How can their numbers be dropping when they seem to be the only major Christian denomination in lockstep with the attitudes and ideals of Canadians?...
This decade the United Church has remained synchronized to society's evolution. Among religious groups it has been the loudest voice in support of same-sex marriage.
We know from the world of business and economics that a product will be successful if it meets the needs of consumers. Why isn't the new and improved United Church achieving market penetration?

Or maybe the problem is people want a church to be about more than giving them what they want. Pope Benedict made that point when he addressed the bishops at World Youth Day Sunday. He called for the bishops to be sure they led
...a Church open to the future, and therefore one full of promise for coming generations. Young people, in fact, are not looking for a Church which panders to youth but one which is truly young in spirit; a Church completely open to Christ, the new Man.

Many Protestant churches have followed the United Church's model of letting the culture set their agenda. They have worked to be churches that meet people where they are. They have tried to be relevant in the terms of modern society. And those churches have all seen steep membership drops.

Which is not to say the Roman Catholic church has not faced its own membership challenges. In the west -- particularly western Europe -- the Roman Catholic participation decline has been as steep as that of the Protestants.

And yet, to see the multitudes who gather for World Youth Day is to see this is a church with a future, and an energy to meet that future. That energy may largely come from congregations in the two-thirds world, what the Anglicans call the Global South, but at least that energy is there.

Perhaps the United Church of Canada would find that same energy if it had the kind of ties to global congregations the Roman Catholic church enjoys. Their own global network is the World Alliance of Reformed Churches, an organization of Presbyterian and Reformed communions, 218 churches in 107 countries with a membership of about 75 million. But somehow, I rather suspect a WARC World Youth Day would not have nearly the level of energy on display at the gathering in Cologne, Germany, last Sunday.