31 December 2006

A little more reverence, please: we dare not deflate all our cherished institutions

For many years, children have sung the twisted holiday carol “Jingle bells, Santa smells, Robin laid an egg...” Kind of irreverent, a little twisted, but not all that far from the classic Spike Jones take on the holiday. “All I want for Christmas is my two front teeth” and “I’m getting nothin’ for Christmas” have a kind of innocence, even if they don’t exactly toe the standard reverent Christmas carol line.

But somehow it feels like a line has been crossed as I heard some children singing “Deck the halls with poison ivy...” That was the beginning; in later lines the song descended into celebrations of decorations causing even more pain and suffering.

Every generation has its own versions of sophomoric comedy. Every society has jesters dancing out on the margins, deflating the solemn traditions of the elders. In previous generations, those impulses have been harmless comic release valves because there was a strong affirmation of the traditions that give shape and form to the culture. And the jesters had the positive value of helping our society avoid the pride that comes from taking itself too seriously.

But what becomes of a generation raised on the sophomoric deflation of the traditions? What if defending the tradition becomes the marginal activity, and deflating it becomes the main thing? Reverence and respect go together. A culture with a strong sense of reverence is a culture that can cultivate a strong sense of mutual respect.

Many people find the Three Stooges funny because they’re so off the wall and unusual. Imagine, though, a world where Curly, Larry, and Moe set the standards for how people should treat one another. Suddenly they’re not so funny. If irreverence displaces reverence, and everything is something of a joke played out for our entertainment, why should any of us take any respectful notice of anyone else?

And I suppose that’s why I find it so troubling to hear kids singing about decking the halls with poison ivy. A little irreverence is harmless. Things begin to fall apart when that cynical impulse begins to displace the traditional ennobling aspirations of the holiday.

Was it Chris Johnson (at the excellent blog Midwest Conservative Journal) who wrote about how nervous he was that the work of defending the core societal institutions was in the hands of a generation that knew more about how to tear down traditions than build them up? Whoever wrote that was onto something important. It will be a challenge to see the problem and rise to the occasion. But can our generation muster the strength to meet that challenge?

If we can, we will truly be heirs of the title “Greatest Generation.”

30 October 2006

The pen is not always mightier: the search for a non-military solution in Afghanistan and Iraq

“The pen is mightier than the sword.” Look it up in a dictionary of cultural literacy or other phrase book, and you’ll find it called an aphorism or adage. It’s a quick, dramatic way of saying in the long run, ideas are what matter. In the long run, the people who write the histories decide who the “good guys” and the “bad guys” are.

You won’t find “the pen is mightier…” listed under practical strategies for self-defence. When accosted by a mugger, the pen is a feeble defence. Later on, you can use your pen to write scathing articles that will shape posterity’s view of the mugger. But in the moment of conflict, the pen is not much use against a knife or pistol.

“The pen is mightier…” is a proverbs of guidance that gives advice about the values we choose. It is not a literal statement of the way things work in the real world. Though these days some politicians seem to act as if it were.

“Bring the troops home” an increasing number of people and leaders say. “There is no military solution.” “We need to pursue negotiations, not confrontations.” Statements like that echo through the halls of government as leaders debate the situations in Iraq and Afghanistan. Somewhere out there is a treaty the parties could sign that would bring peace and stability.

Does anybody remember who the Taliban are? Does anybody remember what they did when they ruled Afghanistan? They executed people for teaching girls! What compromise is there with this kind of ideology?

Does anybody remember why Muqtada al-Sadr is an anti-US cleric? It’s not the lack of progressive social services in the west. It’s things like rock music and freely-available alcohol and the way women can go out in public uncovered. It’s the way we in the west don’t enforce a strict morality like the sharia code.

What potential compromise is there with forces like these? What is there to negotiate about? The Taliban will not change their beliefs on the role of women in society because western troops pull out of the country.

What could we accomplish by bringing the troops home? What kind of agreement waits at the end of the negotiations some say should replace confrontations? Well, there aren’t too many specifics about that. With a resigned shrug of the shoulders, people admit ignorance but hope it will be better than what’s gone before.

Using the pen to sign a treaty may make some in the west feel better, but it’s a weak protection indeed against those who choose to use their swords against their opponents. All the pen really accomplishes there is to put down some ink stains that dry upon some line. And, to borrow the phrases from the Jimmy Webb song, a truly determined person won’t be shackled by those kinds of forgotten words and bonds.

Sometimes we can resist evil with the power of words and ideas – the realm of the pen. But sometimes it takes more. Sometimes it takes the sword. And woe to us and those who count on us for protection if we use a pen when we need the sword.

13 September 2006

On Same-Sex marriage: Changing values for one affects everyone

Why do evangelicals care about how society defines marriage? I often hear or read things like "Expanding the understanding of marriage to embrace homosexuals will have no effect on your marriage. It's just making the definition more inclusive." I beg to differ.

As one of my teachers put it, inclusiveness is simply the transitional form from one orthodoxy to another. It may sound cynical, but it does seem to reflect the reality of history. And it's logically inevitable. No one is simply "inclusive." Everyone is simultaneously "inclusive" and "exclusive." One can not include this without at the same time excluding all that is notthis.

An "inclusive" society can not embrace homosexuality as morally equivalent to heterosexuality without also excluding those who do not regard it as equivalent. Witness how many times people who do little more than quote or publish Bible verses are considered guilty of impermissible "hate speech" -- and how much harsher the treatment can be for those who enthusiastically advocate the historic church teaching.

The pro-Same-Sex marriage position is not simply a move to expand the definition of marriage. It is a move to completely change the root meaning of marriage. The traditional definition -- in quick summary form -- focuses on providing a stable environment for care and nurture, of children especially, but for families generally. The biological case is obvious.

The psychological case is subtle, but also clear. Children grow up best in an environment with strong, positive male and female role models acting in balance. For example, boys who do not grow up seeing a father work and sacrifice for the good of his family will tend to be self-focused themselves. That was the impulse behind Big Brothers and other mentoring projects: if a boy does not have a positive male role model in his own family, then the society should provide him one.

The pro-Same-Sex marriage definition changes the focus of marriage. It moves the focus from the care and nurture of children and families. Marriage becomes focused on defining, regularizing, and regulating the sexual conduct of adults. Children become a secondary issue. The main thing is the emotional and social fulfillment of the adults in question.

How far will this go? For example, if a lesbian couple wants to fulfill their desire to be parents, and especially if one deeply feels a need to be a mother, will they be entitled to costly fertility treatments so they can bear children? I've read reports of these kinds of claims being made on the public health care system. Having embraced their marriage life as a family just like any other, on what basis can society say no? But if we say yes, how do we pay for this care? The health care system is already strained to the breaking point: what further cuts will we make to free these funds?

I tend not to be a individualistic libertarian. When people say "these changes in values will have no effect on you and your values," I do not easily agree. We are all connected to one another by a subtle tapestry of relationships and influences, and should exercise great care before we pull too hard on one loose thread. As the saying goes, All humanity "is of one author, and is one volume; ... [T]he bell that rings to a sermon, calls not upon the preacher only, but upon the congregation to come..." No one is an island, separatate and unconnected; we are all part of the mainland, joined, united, connected to one another.

02 September 2006

"In spite of that, keep going anyway": How Baseball is like life

"The game begins in the spring, when everything is new again, and it blossoms in the summer, filling the afternoons and evenings, and then as soon as the chill rains comes, it stops, and leaves you to face the fall alone."

That's from the beginning of Bart Giamatti's famous essay "The Green Fields of the Mind" Baseball fans, he writes, "count on it, rely on it to buffer the passage of time, to keep the memory of sunshine and high skies alive, and then just when the days are all twilight, when you need it most, it stops."

Baseball is such an odd game. Unlike, say, basketball, where teams seem to score almost every time they have the ball, baseball players see much less success. A .300 hitter is considered excellent -- yet that means he fails seven out of ten times.

The central focus of the game is the individual contest between pitcher and batter. And yet that context means nothing apart from the support of the rest of the team. A batter may defy the odds and reach base. Yet, that achievement means nothing if the batter behind him hits into a double play. Several times this season, one of the kids on our mites (ages 6 to 9 years) softball team has complained "It's not fair. Why do I have to go back to the dugout? He hit the ball to the fielder!"

Many people have said it: "Learning to deal with failure is one of the keys to succeeding in baseball." This is the time of year when that becomes most real. In most other sports, the last weeks are about playoffs, either getting set up for a good start, or making the final push to qualify. Not baseball. There are just four slots for the playoffs, and come September 1, there aren't many teams with a realistic shot at those four places.

Looking over the standings today, I found myself calculating what my team would have to do to avoid having the worst record in baseball. Not what they would have to do to win the playoffs -- or even just make the playoffs. Baseball has no Cinderella teams who start the playoffs in the eighth seed but overachieve to make it to the seventh game of the finals.

In that way, baseball is a lot like life. It's about doing your best day in and day out. Not because it's going to get you a shot at the championship. Not because it's going to get you a shot at glory. Just because it's the right thing to do. Just because there are people around you pulling for you, counting on you to lift them up.

Let us not become weary in doing good, for at the proper time we will reap a harvest if we do not give up. Galatians 6:9
And as for you, brothers, never tire of doing what is right. 2 Thessalonians 3:13
Therefore, since we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses, let us throw off everything that hinders and the sin that so easily entangles, and let us run with perseverance the race marked out for us. Hebrews 12:1

Most of us don't rise from obscurity to become successful heads of corporations or wealthy movie stars or powerful civic leaders. In spite of that, we just keep going anyway. We do our best day by day, just because it's the right thing to do.